Recipe No 1111 sauce Adapted 2026

Homemade Ketchup

Homemade ketchup can be tuned to personal taste, and this version is adapted from a very spicy recipe by ChgoJohn. It cuts back on the spices and changes the cooking times. Canned tomatoes are used because they beat the fresh ones available locally; if using fresh, choose very ripe tomatoes, as appearance does not matter. For a more basic ketchup, many of the spices can be left out.

Stefan’s original recipe is superbly presented, including step-by-step images. Worth checking out.

Time

Prep

Total

Shelf life

Fridge5 days

Difficulty

easy

Yield

Weight1200 g

Processes

  • Red bell pepper (1)
    120 g
  • Onions1 (2 medium)
    220 g
  • Jalapeño (1)
    14 g
  • Garlic (2 cloves)
    6 g
  1. 01
    Roughly chop the bell pepper, onions, jalapeño, and garlic.

  • Peeled tomatoes (1 big can)
    2500 g
  1. 02
    Pour the tomatoes with the juices in a casserole or Dutch oven.
  2. 03
    Add the chopped vegetables.
  3. 04
    Stir and bring to a boil.
  4. 05
    Reduce the heat to a simmer and cook, uncovered, until the vegetables are soft, about .
  5. 06
    Pass the mixture through a food mill twice.
  6. 07
    First with a coarse sieve.
  7. 08
    And then with a fine sieve, to get smooth ketchup. (If you were to go straight to the fine sieve, you would have a very hard time getting the ketchup through. That is why you should start with the coarse sieve.)

  • Cider vinegar (120 ml)
    120 g
  1. 09
    Return the tomato mixture to the casserole. Add the vinegar.

  • Dark brown sugar (¼ cup + 2 tbsp)
    55 g
  1. 10
    Add the sugar.

  • Dry mustard (¼ tsp)
    0.48 g
  • Smoked paprika (1 tsp)
    2.3 g
  1. 11
    Add the mustard and paprika.

  • Cinnamon stick (1 stick)
    4.5 g
  • Whole cloves (1 tsp)
    2.2 g
  • Whole allspice (1 tsp)
    1.9 g
  • Mace (1 tsp)
    1.7 g
  • Celery seeds (1 tsp)
    2 g
  • Black peppercorns (1 tbsp)
    2.4 g
  • Bay leaf (1)
    4 g
  1. 12
    Make a spice pouch with the cinnamon, cloves, allspice, mace, celery seeds, peppercorns and bay leaf. For this you can use a piece of muslin or a disposable hairnet
  2. 13
    Add the spice pouch to the casserole. The pouch will allow the spices to give off their flavor without the spices ending up in the ketchup.
  3. 14
    Bring to a boil, stirring. Reduce the heat to a simmer and cook, uncovered, for .2
  4. 15
    After , remove the spice pouch.
  5. 16
    Simmer the ketchup until it has the desired strength and thickness. This can take an hour or longer.
  6. 17
    To try the ketchup, freeze a small dish for half an hour. Put a teaspoon of the ketchup on the dish to cool it quickly. Then taste the ketchup. As ketchup is eaten at room temperature, it is better to taste it this way instead of when it’s still warm. If the ketchup is still too thin or not strong enough, simmer it longer until it is to your liking.

  • Cayenne pepper
    to taste
  • Nutmeg, freshly grated
    to taste
  • Salt
    to taste
  1. 18
    Finally, season the ketchup to your liking with salt, freshly grated nutmeg, and cayenne pepper.
  2. 19
    Put it in clean (sterlized) jars when it is still hot, and turn over the jars to allow the hot ketchup to sterilize the jar from the inside after it has been closed. When handled like this, the ketchup will keep for a very long time in the refrigerator.3

Shopping list

  1. A combination of 1 red and 1 white works well.
  2. You can make the ketchup more or less spicy by leaving the spice pouch in for a longer or shorter cooking time.
  3. If you are into canning, you could process the jars to be able to store the ketchup at room temperature.

Hot! Be careful when sterlizing the jars.

Makes about 1.2 ℓ / 1¼ qt.

If you do use fresh tomatoes instead of canned, make sure they are very ripe. It’s okay if they don’t look perfect.

Many of the spices can be left out to make a more basic ketchup.

Prepare the spice pouch and chop the vegetables .

Put it in clean (sterlized) jars when it is still hot and store in the refrigerator. Lasts for about 5 days after opening.

Finished recipe

Comments

Add yours

0 / 1200

Categorisation

Type
condiment sauce
Meal
basics condiment
Diet
dairy free gluten free vegan vegetarian
Tags
homemade jalapeño ketchup spice pouch tomatoes